EMA Crossover Strategy (9/21): 10 Years of Backtest Results
The 9/21 EMA crossover is one of the most common first strategies: buy when the fast average crosses above the slow one, sell when it crosses below, and use the 200 EMA to stay with the trend.
We tested it on 10 years of 1-hour data on five markets. It lost on the three FX and metals markets, and made money on Nasdaq futures.
- EUR/USD 1-hour, 10 years: 1,257 trades, 33% winners, profit factor 0.94, −46.9% at 1% risk.
- GBP/USD (0.94) and gold (0.95) lost by similar amounts.
- Nasdaq 100 futures made money: profit factor 1.12 and +103.3% over 1,070 trades, with a −25.5% drawdown.
- Year to year it swings hard on EUR/USD: +26.8R in 2021, −39.8R in 2022.
In this guide: The exact rules · The result on EUR/USD · Same rules on 5 markets · What to try instead
The exact rules
Buy when the 9 EMA crosses above the 21 EMA and price is above the 200 EMA. Sell when the 9 EMA crosses below the 21 EMA and price is below the 200 EMA. Stop at 1.5x ATR. Target 2R.
1-hour candles, November 2016 to November 2026, 1% risk per trade, spread and commission included. See moving averages and ATR if any of that is new.
The result on EUR/USD
!img /media/blog/ema-crossover-strategy/e-equity.webp | Equity curve of the 9/21 EMA crossover on EUR/USD 1-hour over 10 years, down 46.9% | 1,257 trades on EUR/USD. Long rallies, then deeper drops.
1,257 trades, 33% winners, a profit factor of 0.94, an average of −0.04R per trade and −46.9% at 1% risk, with a maximum drawdown of −51.3%. Numbers are from the WickCheck strategy library as of 19 November 2026. The library re-runs every test as new candles arrive, so the live pages can differ slightly.
!img /media/blog/ema-crossover-strategy/e-years.webp | Year-by-year results of the EMA crossover on EUR/USD in R | Year by year on EUR/USD. Great trending years and terrible choppy ones.
The yearly results show why crossovers are so frustrating: 2021 made +26.8R and 2022 lost −39.8R. Crossovers do well when markets trend and get chopped up when they don't, and you can't tell in advance which kind of year you're in.
Same rules on 5 markets
!img /media/blog/ema-crossover-strategy/e-markets.webp | Profit factor of the 9/21 EMA crossover on EUR/USD, GBP/USD, gold, Nasdaq futures and Bitcoin | Nasdaq futures were the clear exception.
- EUR/USD: 0.94, −46.9%.
- GBP/USD: 0.94, −50.1%.
- Gold: 0.95, −42.8%.
- Nasdaq 100 futures: 1.12, +103.3% (maximum drawdown −25.5%).
- Bitcoin: 1.03, +15.4%.
Nasdaq trended strongly for most of the decade, which is exactly the environment a crossover needs. That's a property of the market, not proof that the rule works everywhere.
What to try instead
- Slower averages. The golden cross (50/200) traded rarely and held up on every market tested, but on very few trades.
- A breakout instead of a crossover. The 20-day breakout is also trend-following and was profitable on all 9 markets tested.
- A higher timeframe. The same crossover on 4-hour or daily candles trades less and pays less in spreads.
Bottom line. The 9/21 EMA crossover lost money on EUR/USD, GBP/USD and gold over 10 years of 1-hour data and only clearly worked on Nasdaq futures. Its results depend almost entirely on whether the market trends.
Change the averages, the timeframe or the filter in plain English.
Questions
- Does the 9/21 EMA crossover strategy work?
- In WickCheck's 10-year 1-hour test with a 200 EMA filter, it lost on EUR/USD (profit factor 0.94), GBP/USD and gold, and was profitable on Nasdaq 100 futures (1.12) and slightly on Bitcoin (1.03).
- What is the best EMA crossover for day trading?
- There's no single best pair. Results depend far more on the market and timeframe than on the exact numbers. Test the pair you want to use on your market before trading it.
- Why do moving average crossovers lose in ranging markets?
- In a range the averages cross back and forth, giving many small losing signals. Crossovers only make money when a trend lasts long enough to pay for those losses.
Keep reading
The golden cross (50 SMA crossing the 200 SMA) backtested since 1993 on SPY and on 7 other markets. Strong profit factors, but very few trades.
20-Day Breakout (Donchian) Strategy: 9 Markets, 10 Years TestedThe Turtle-style 20-day breakout, backtested on gold, indices, oil, EUR/USD and stocks over 10 years with costs. Profitable on all 9 markets tested.
MACD Crossover Strategy: 10-Year Backtest on Forex, Gold and IndicesThe MACD signal-line crossover with a 200 EMA filter, tested on 10 years of 4-hour data. Profitable on EUR/USD, gold, S&P 500 futures and Bitcoin.
EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest ShowsWe tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Educational content, not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.