MACD Crossover Strategy: 10-Year Backtest on Forex, Gold and Indices
MACD is one of the most used indicators in trading, and the signal-line crossover is its most common rule. We tested it with a 200 EMA trend filter on 10 years of 4-hour candles.
Unlike most popular indicator strategies we've tested, this one was modestly profitable on most markets.
- EUR/USD 4-hour, 10 years: 498 trades, 36% winners, profit factor 1.09, +25.9% at 1% risk.
- Gold did best: profit factor 1.16 and +59.1%, with a −26.7% drawdown.
- S&P 500 futures (1.06) and Bitcoin (1.09) were also profitable; GBP/USD lost (0.96).
- Two short 2-year stock tests (SPY 0.86, Tesla 0.59) lost, on far fewer trades.
In this guide: The exact rules · The result on EUR/USD · Same rules on 7 markets · Why it held up when faster indicator strategies didn't
The exact rules
Buy when MACD crosses above the signal line and price is above the 200 EMA. Sell when MACD crosses below the signal line and price is below the 200 EMA. Stop at 1.5x ATR. Target 2R.
4-hour candles, November 2016 to November 2026 (stocks: 2 years), 1% risk per trade, spread and commission included. More on the indicator itself in MACD.
The result on EUR/USD
!img /media/blog/macd-crossover-strategy/f-equity.webp | Equity curve of the MACD crossover on EUR/USD 4-hour over 10 years, up 25.9% | 498 trades on EUR/USD 4-hour. Profitable, but with long flat stretches.
498 trades, 36% winners, a profit factor of 1.09, an average of +0.06R per trade and +25.9% at 1% risk, with a maximum drawdown of −16.9%. Numbers are from the WickCheck strategy library as of 19 November 2026. The library re-runs every test as new candles arrive, so the live pages can differ slightly.
!img /media/blog/macd-crossover-strategy/f-years.webp | Year-by-year results of the MACD crossover on EUR/USD in R | Year by year on EUR/USD: four losing years out of ten.
Four of the ten years lost money (2018, 2019, 2021 and 2025). The best were 2017 (+15.4R), 2022 (+11.1R) and 2020 (+10.2R). A thin edge like this needs years of patience.
Same rules on 7 markets
!img /media/blog/macd-crossover-strategy/f-markets.webp | Profit factor of the MACD crossover on EUR/USD, GBP/USD, gold, S&P 500 futures, Bitcoin, SPY and Tesla | Profitable on four of the five 10-year tests. The two stock tests only cover 2 years.
- Gold: 1.16, +59.1% (496 trades).
- EUR/USD: 1.09, +25.9%.
- Bitcoin: 1.09, +27.9%.
- S&P 500 futures: 1.06, +15.1%.
- GBP/USD: 0.96, −18.2%.
- SPY (2 years, 40 trades): 0.86, −4.5%.
- Tesla (2 years, 44 trades): 0.59, −13.3%.
The stock results are on 40–44 trades, too few to mean much in either direction; see sample size.
Why it held up when faster indicator strategies didn't
Compare it with the 9/21 EMA crossover on 1-hour data, which lost on EUR/USD. The MACD test runs on 4-hour candles, so it trades about 50 times a year instead of 125. Fewer trades means less paid in spreads, and each trade has more room to work. That alone can turn a break-even idea into a small positive one.
It's still a modest edge: +0.06R per trade on EUR/USD. Treat it as a starting point to improve and test, not a finished system.
Bottom line. The MACD signal-line crossover with a 200 EMA filter made money on four of five markets over 10 years of 4-hour data, best on gold. The edge is thin and the yearly results are uneven.
Same rules on any market and timeframe, or change any word.
Questions
- Is the MACD crossover strategy profitable?
- In WickCheck's 10-year 4-hour test with a 200 EMA filter it was profitable on EUR/USD (profit factor 1.09), gold (1.16), S&P 500 futures (1.06) and Bitcoin (1.09), and lost on GBP/USD (0.96).
- What timeframe is best for MACD?
- In our tests, slower timeframes held up better because fewer trades means lower costs. The 4-hour test was profitable on EUR/USD while faster crossover strategies on 1-hour data lost.
- Does MACD work on stocks?
- Our two stock tests (SPY and Tesla) only cover 2 years and about 40 trades each, and both lost. That is too few trades to judge either way; the 10-year tests on futures, forex, gold and Bitcoin are more reliable.
Keep reading
The 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA trend filter, backtested on 10 years of 1-hour data on EUR/USD, GBP/USD, gold, Nasdaq and Bitcoin.
Buying When RSI Is Oversold: 10 Years of Backtest ResultsThe classic RSI(14) 30/70 strategy with a 200 EMA filter, backtested on 10 years of 1-hour data on EUR/USD, gold, S&P 500, GBP/USD and Bitcoin.
Which Trading Strategies Actually Work? 15 Backtested on Real DataWe backtested 15 popular trading strategies, from ICT setups to RSI and moving averages, on years of real data with costs. Here is what held up.
EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest ShowsWe tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Educational content, not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.