20-Day Breakout (Donchian) Strategy: 9 Markets, 10 Years Tested
The 20-day breakout is one of the oldest trend-following rules in trading. It was the core of the Turtle traders' system: buy when price makes a new 20-day high, sell when it makes a new 20-day low. Simple enough to fit in a tweet, and still one of the most discussed rules online.
We tested a version with a trend filter, an ATR stop and a 2R target on 10 years of daily data across 9 markets. It was profitable on every one of them.
- Profitable on all 9 markets tested over 10 years, with costs: profit factors from 1.19 to 1.79.
- Main test on gold: 82 trades, 46% win rate, profit factor 1.68, +34.5% at 1% risk, max drawdown −9.6%.
- It wins less than half the time. The edge comes from winners about twice the size of losers.
- Two losing years on gold (2017 and 2021): a real edge still needs patience.
In this guide: The exact rules · Results on gold · Results on 9 markets · Why a 46% win rate still works · What to test next
The exact rules
Buy when price breaks above the 20-day high and price is above the 200 SMA. Sell when price breaks below the 20-day low and price is below the 200 SMA. Stop at 2x ATR. Target 2R.
WickCheck reads that as: long when the close is above the 20-bar high and above the 200-day SMA, short when the close is below the 20-bar low and below the 200-day SMA, a stop at 2× ATR(14) and a target at twice the risk. Daily candles, 1% risk per trade, costs included.
Results on gold
Over 10 years of daily gold (XAU/USD) data the rule took 82 trades, won 46% of them and reached a profit factor of 1.68, an average of +0.37R per trade, +34.5% at 1% risk per trade and a maximum drawdown of −9.6%.
Year by year it was not a straight line. 2017 lost 6.3R and 2021 lost 5.0R. The strongest year was 2025 at +13.0R, when gold trended hard. That is typical of trend-following: long flat or losing stretches, then a few big moves pay for everything. Numbers are from the WickCheck strategy library as of 18 November 2026. The library re-runs every test as new candles arrive, so the live pages may differ slightly.
Results on 9 markets
- QQQ (Nasdaq 100 ETF): 91 trades, profit factor 1.79, +45.2%.
- Nvidia: 93 trades, profit factor 1.69, +41.5%.
- Gold: 82 trades, profit factor 1.68, +34.5%.
- EUR/USD: 48 trades, profit factor 1.62, +16.8%.
- Nasdaq 100 futures: 81 trades, profit factor 1.52, +25.7%.
- S&P 500 futures: 82 trades, profit factor 1.48, +24.2%.
- Crude oil: 72 trades, profit factor 1.44, +19.7%.
- Apple: 95 trades, profit factor 1.37, +22.0%.
- SPY: 93 trades, profit factor 1.19, +10.9%.
Identical rules working across commodities, currencies, indices and single stocks is much stronger evidence than one great market. It is the opposite of overfitting.
Why a 46% win rate still works
With a 2R target, the rule breaks even before costs at a win rate of about 33%. At 46% wins of roughly 2R against losses of 1R, the expectancy is positive even after spreads. Our guide to tracking trading profit and loss shows the expectancy math, and risk management covers why 1% risk matters with a strategy that can lose several times in a row.
What to test next
- Different channel lengths: 55-day breakouts were the Turtles' slower system.
- Trailing exits instead of a fixed 2R target, to let the big trends run.
- Other markets you trade: the full test page has a button for each market that opens the exact test in WickCheck.
WickCheck reads the rules in plain English, so changing '20-day' to '55-day' is a one-word edit. No code.
Bottom line. A simple breakout with a trend filter, a volatility stop and a 2R target held up on every market we tried over 10 years. Expect fewer than half your trades to win, and some losing years.
Same rules, same data. Change any word and see the result in seconds.
Questions
- Does the Donchian breakout strategy still work?
- In WickCheck's 10-year test with costs, a 20-day breakout with a 200-day SMA filter, 2 ATR stop and 2R target was profitable on all 9 markets tested, with profit factors between 1.19 (SPY) and 1.79 (QQQ).
- What is the win rate of the 20-day breakout?
- Between about 38% and 47% depending on the market; 46% on gold. The strategy makes money because winners average about twice the size of losers.
- What is the Turtle trading strategy?
- The Turtle traders used channel breakouts: buying new 20-day or 55-day highs and selling new lows, with position sizing based on volatility. The 20-day breakout tested here is a simplified version with a trend filter and a fixed 2R target.
Keep reading
We backtested 15 popular trading strategies, from ICT setups to RSI and moving averages, on years of real data with costs. Here is what held up.
Risk Management in Trading: The 1% Rule, Stops and DrawdownA practical guide to trading risk management: the 1% rule, stop losses, risk to reward, drawdown math and daily loss limits, with worked numbers.
Losing Streaks in Trading: How Many Losses in a Row Are Normal?How long losing streaks get at different win rates, the exact odds over 100 trades, what they cost at 1% risk, and how to survive them.
EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest ShowsWe tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Educational content, not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.