Golden Cross Strategy Backtest: 33 Years of the 50/200 SMA
The golden cross is the moving average signal everyone has heard of: the 50-day moving average crossing above the 200-day. Financial news covers it every time it happens on the S&P 500.
We tested the simplest version, buy the golden cross and sell the death cross, on SPY since 1993 and on 7 other markets. The profit factors are high. The trade counts are tiny, and that matters just as much.
- SPY since 1993: 15 trades, 47% win rate, profit factor 3.53, +21.8% at 1% risk, max drawdown −4.9%.
- Profitable on all 8 markets tested, but with only 11 to 30 trades per market.
- Few trades means a result that can still be luck. Treat it as a long-term trend filter, not a proven system.
In this guide: The exact rules · Results on SPY since 1993 · Results on 8 markets · Why so few trades is a problem · How traders use it instead
The exact rules
Buy when the 50 SMA crosses above the 200 SMA. Exit when the 50 SMA crosses below the 200 SMA. Stop at 3x ATR.
Daily candles, long only, 1% risk per trade with the stop at 3× ATR(14), costs included. The exit is the death cross, the opposite signal.
Results on SPY since 1993
From January 1993 to November 2026 the rule took 15 trades: 47% winners, a profit factor of 3.53, an average of +1.36R per trade, +21.8% at 1% risk and a maximum drawdown of only −4.9%.
Fifteen trades in almost 34 years is the whole story of this strategy. Most years have no trade at all. The winners were big trend years such as 2007 (+5.5R), 2022 (+5.7R) and 2026 (+6.5R), while many signals were small losses of about 1R each. Numbers are from the WickCheck strategy library as of 18 November 2026. The library re-runs every test as new candles arrive, so the live pages may differ slightly.
Results on 8 markets
- Bitcoin (since 2014): 11 trades, profit factor 52.47.
- QQQ (since 1999): 17 trades, profit factor 11.27.
- Nasdaq 100 futures (since 2000): 16 trades, profit factor 11.13.
- S&P 500 futures (since 2000): 12 trades, profit factor 6.80.
- Microsoft (since 1986): 29 trades, profit factor 6.43.
- Apple (since 1980): 30 trades, profit factor 5.43.
- SPY (since 1993): 15 trades, profit factor 3.53.
- Gold (since 2000): 15 trades, profit factor 2.95.
Every market made money, but look at the trade counts. With 11 to 30 trades, a couple of huge trends can produce an enormous profit factor. Bitcoin's 52.47 comes from 11 trades during one of the biggest bull runs of any asset.
Why so few trades is a problem
A profit factor is only as reliable as the number of trades behind it. Under about 30 trades, one or two outliers decide everything; see sample size. The golden cross also only tests one kind of market: long-term bull trends in assets that have gone up a lot over the period.
There is a practical problem too. You can wait years for a signal and sit through deep pullbacks inside a trade. Most traders will not stick with a system that does nothing for years, which is part of why it keeps working on paper. See trading psychology.
How traders use it instead
Many traders use the golden cross as a regime filter rather than a system: only take long setups when the 50 SMA is above the 200 SMA. That is exactly what the RSI(2) pullback and the 20-day breakout do with their 200-day SMA filters, and both have far more trades to judge. You can test either combination in WickCheck in plain English.
Bottom line. The golden cross made money on every market we tested, with very high profit factors, but on so few trades that it is better treated as a long-term trend filter than a proven trading system.
Same rules on any market, or add it as a filter to your own strategy.
Questions
- Does the golden cross strategy work?
- In WickCheck's test it made money on all 8 markets, with a profit factor of 3.53 on SPY since 1993. But it produced only 11 to 30 trades per market, which is too few to call it proven.
- How often does a golden cross happen?
- Rarely. On SPY the 50/200 SMA crossover produced 15 trades between 1993 and 2026, so many years have no signal at all.
- What is the difference between a golden cross and a death cross?
- A golden cross is the 50-day moving average crossing above the 200-day; a death cross is the 50-day crossing below it. In this test the golden cross is the entry and the death cross is the exit.
Keep reading
We backtested 15 popular trading strategies, from ICT setups to RSI and moving averages, on years of real data with costs. Here is what held up.
20-Day Breakout (Donchian) Strategy: 9 Markets, 10 Years TestedThe Turtle-style 20-day breakout, backtested on gold, indices, oil, EUR/USD and stocks over 10 years with costs. Profitable on all 9 markets tested.
Bollinger Band Bounce Strategy: 10-Year Backtest With CostsA Bollinger band mean reversion strategy backtested over 10 years on S&P 500 futures, gold, EUR/USD and more. Profitable on 7 of 8 markets after costs.
EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest ShowsWe tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Educational content, not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.