WickCheck / Trading school / Blog
Backtesting

How to Read Backtest Results: Win Rate, Profit Factor and Drawdown

19 November 2026 · 4 min read · by the WickCheck team

A backtest gives you six or seven numbers, and most traders only look at one of them, usually the return. Here is a real report, the 20-day breakout on 10 years of daily gold, explained number by number.

By the end you'll know which numbers matter, which ones mislead, and what to check before you trust any result.

Key takeaways
  • Start with the number of trades: under about 30, nothing else is reliable.
  • Win rate means nothing without the size of the wins. 45% wins at 2R is profitable; 60% wins at 0.5R is not.
  • Profit factor above 1 means the strategy made money after costs. Average trade in R tells you how much per trade.
  • Max drawdown is the worst drop from a peak. It's the number that decides whether you can actually trade it.
  • Always check the year-by-year table and other markets before trusting one good result.

In this guide: The report · 1. Trades: 82 · 2. Win rate: 45% · 3. Profit factor: 1.65 · 4. Average trade: +0.36R · 5. Max drawdown: −9.6% · 6. Return: +32.7% · Check the years · Check other markets

The report

!img /media/blog/how-to-read-a-backtest/i1-report.webp | Backtest report for the 20-day breakout on gold: 82 trades, 45% win rate, profit factor 1.65, +0.36R average trade, -9.6% max drawdown, +32.7% return | 20-day breakout on gold, daily, 10 years, 1% risk per trade, costs included.

This is the 20-day breakout on daily gold from November 2016 to November 2026, with costs and 1% risk per trade. Numbers are from the WickCheck strategy library as of 19 November 2026. The library re-runs every test as new candles arrive, so the live pages can differ slightly.

1. Trades: 82

The number of trades is how much evidence you have. 82 trades over 10 years is enough to take seriously but not enough to be sure. Under about 30 trades, a couple of lucky outliers can make anything look good; see sample size. Very high counts (thousands) make costs matter much more.

2. Win rate: 45%

Less than half the trades won, and the strategy still made money. That's because each win was about 2R and each loss 1R. With a 2R target, the break-even win rate before costs is about 33%. Win rate on its own tells you nothing; it only matters next to the size of the wins and losses.

3. Profit factor: 1.65

Profit factor is total profit divided by total loss. 1.00 is break-even, below 1 loses money. 1.65 means for every $1 lost, $1.65 was made. About half of the 15 popular strategies in our library landed between 0.8 and 1.1; anything consistently above about 1.3 over a decent sample is unusual.

4. Average trade: +0.36R

The expectancy: on average each trade made 0.36 times the amount risked. The math is roughly 45% × 2R − 55% × 1R = +0.35R, and costs and small differences account for the rest. At 1% risk, that's about +0.36% per trade. If this number is close to zero, a small change in costs can flip the whole result.

5. Max drawdown: −9.6%

Drawdown is the biggest drop from a peak in the account before it recovered. Here it was 9.6% at 1% risk. Double the risk and you roughly double the drawdown. Ask yourself whether you'd keep trading the rules through a drop that size, because that's what the test says will happen.

6. Return: +32.7%

The total return at 1% risk per trade over the whole period. It's the least useful number on its own: it depends on the risk you choose and the length of the test. Compare it with the drawdown: +32.7% for a worst drop of 9.6% is a reasonable ratio.

Check the years

!img /media/blog/how-to-read-a-backtest/i2-years.webp | Year-by-year results of the 20-day breakout on gold: two losing years, best year 2025 | Two losing years out of ten. 2025 alone made 13.0R.

Ten years can hide a lot. This strategy lost 7.4R in 2017 and 5.0R in 2021, and made 13.0R in 2025 alone. If most of the profit comes from one year, the edge is fragile. Here eight of ten years were positive, which is a good sign.

Check other markets

One market can be luck. The same 20-day breakout rules were profitable on all 9 markets in the library test: gold, S&P 500 and Nasdaq futures, oil, EUR/USD, SPY, QQQ, Nvidia and Apple. That's far stronger evidence than gold alone. See the full write-up in the 20-day breakout strategy.

The checklist: enough trades, positive profit factor after costs, a drawdown you can live with, most years positive, and similar results on other markets. More in how to backtest a trading strategy.

Bottom line. Read a backtest in this order: trades, profit factor, average trade, drawdown, then the year-by-year table and other markets. Win rate and total return matter least on their own.

Get this report for your own strategy

Type your rules in plain English and get every number on this page in seconds.

Run a free backtest

Questions

What is a good profit factor?
Above 1.0 means the strategy made money after costs. About half of the popular strategies in WickCheck's library landed between 0.8 and 1.1; a profit factor consistently above about 1.3 on a decent number of trades is unusual.
Is a high win rate good?
Not on its own. A 45% win rate with 2R winners is profitable, while a 60% win rate with winners half the size of the losers loses money. Look at the average trade in R.
How many trades does a backtest need?
As a rough rule, at least 30, and ideally 100 or more. Under 30 trades, one or two outliers can decide the result.

Keep reading

What a Good Equity Curve Looks Like: 5 Real Backtests Compared

Five real equity curves from tested trading strategies: steady, lumpy, thin, slow bleed and cliff. What each shape tells you before you risk money.

How to Backtest a Trading Strategy (Without Fooling Yourself)

Backtest a trading strategy properly: precise rules, real data, costs, enough trades, out-of-sample checks and the mistakes that create fake results.

20-Day Breakout (Donchian) Strategy: 9 Markets, 10 Years Tested

The Turtle-style 20-day breakout, backtested on gold, indices, oil, EUR/USD and stocks over 10 years with costs. Profitable on all 9 markets tested.

EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest Shows

We tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.

Follow WickCheck for a new strategy test every day: Instagram · TikTok · X

Educational content, not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.

One tested strategy a week

A popular strategy backtested on real data, with the honest numbers. Free, one email a week, unsubscribe any time.