WickCheck / Trading school / Blog

ICT Silver Bullet on Nasdaq vs S&P 500 Futures

14 November 2026 · 5 min read · tested on real data with costs

The ICT Silver Bullet is a one-hour setup that shows up often on trading videos. The idea is simple to state: between 10:00 and 11:00 New York time, wait for price to sweep a liquidity level, then enter on a fair value gap in the direction of the reversal. The question for a trader is whether the rules hold up on a real price series, and whether the setup works better on Nasdaq futures (NQ) or S&P 500 futures (ES).

The short answer is that neither market produced a profitable result in this test. NQ returned -11.8% at 1% risk per trade with a profit factor of 0.46. ES did better but still lost money, with a return of -2.1% and a profit factor of 0.9. Both samples are small, so the comparison is more useful as a warning about the rules than as a ranking of the two markets.

The rules we tested

Between 10:00 and 11:00 New York time, wait for a liquidity sweep, then wait for a fair value gap. Enter on the FVG. Stop above the sweep. Target liquidity, at least 2R.

Results

MarketTradesWin rateProfit factorNetMax DDPeriod
NQ 5m2718.5%0.46-11.8%-11.8%1y
ES 5m2630.8%0.90-2.1%-7.6%1y

1% risk per trade, spread and slippage included, entries at the next candle open, stop checked before target. Periods: NQ 2025-11-12 to 2026-11-13 · ES 2025-11-12 to 2026-11-13.

-4%-2%0%

Equity (% at 1% risk per trade) on ES 5m, 26 trades.

What was tested and why

The test ran on 5-minute bars for both NQ and ES, covering 2025-11-12 to 2026-11-13. Trades were taken in both directions. The engine read the rules as follows: within the 10:00 to 11:00 New York session, it looked for a sweep of any untaken high or low, meaning swing points, equal highs or lows, the previous day, or session levels. After that sweep, it looked for a fair value gap, with each step required to occur within 20 bars of the last.

Entries were placed as a limit order at the edge of the fair value gap. The stop sat beyond the sweep wick, and the target was the nearest liquidity at least 2R away. Costs for spread and slippage are included, and each trade risked 1% of the account. If a stop and a target were both hit inside the same candle, the stop was counted first.

The test is deliberately strict about the sequence. A trade needs the sweep, then the gap, then the fill. That is a narrower version of many videos, which often describe the setup loosely, so a result here applies to these exact rules and not to every discretionary version of the idea.

Results by market

NQ produced 27 trades over the period, 13 long and 14 short. The win rate was 18.5%, the average result was -0.46R per trade, and the profit factor was 0.46. The net return at 1% risk was -11.8%, with a maximum drawdown of 11.8%. A profit factor below 1 means the strategy lost money after costs, and that is what happened here.

ES produced 26 trades, 11 long and 15 short. The win rate was 30.8%, the average result was -0.07R, and the profit factor was 0.9. The net return was -2.1% with a maximum drawdown of 7.6%. This is closer to break-even than NQ, but it is still a losing result after costs, not a flat one.

Both markets have fewer than 30 trades, which is the minimum where we consider a sample more than a handful of outcomes. With 27 and 26 trades, the win rates and profit factors could shift a lot with a few different fills, so neither result should be read as reliable on its own.

What stands out: years and direction

The split by year shows a pattern that is worth noting, though it rests on small numbers. On NQ, the 2025 portion had 5 trades and no wins, with a total of -5.7R. The 2026 portion had 22 trades, 5 wins, and a total of -6.6R. Most of the NQ sample came from 2026, and that is where most of the losses sat.

On ES, 2025 had 6 trades, 2 wins, and a total of -0.1R. 2026 had 20 trades, 6 wins, and a total of -1.7R. ES lost less in total R in both years, and its win rate was higher in each. Its losses were also smaller on average, which is consistent with the better profit factor.

Direction was roughly balanced in both markets. NQ had 13 longs and 14 shorts, and ES had 11 longs and 15 shorts. The sample does not show that one side carried the result, and with this few trades a directional split should not be over-read.

Why it might behave this way

One plausible reason for the gap between the two markets is how each one moves inside the session. NQ tends to produce wider bars and sharper sweeps, which can make the stop beyond the wick large relative to the 2R target. When the stop is wide, costs take a bigger bite out of each R, and a sharp reversal has to clear more distance before it reaches the target. This is an explanation to check, not something this test measured directly.

A second possibility is that the rules rely on a sequence that is hard to hit cleanly in a single hour. Only 26 and 27 trades appeared across a full year, which suggests that the full three-step chain (sweep, gap, fill within 20 bars) is rare in this window. Rare setups tend to produce small samples, and small samples are easy to misread in either direction.

Finally, the choice of timeframe and session may matter. A different bar size or a different window could change which sweeps count and which gaps get filled. The engine read the rules as written, but there is no evidence here about how the setup would behave under different parameters.

What to try next

The most useful next step is a longer history. A single year with fewer than 30 trades per market is not enough to separate a real edge from noise, so extending the test window on both NQ and ES would give a better read on whether the results hold.

It would also be worth testing whether the 2R minimum target is the main drag. Running the same rules with a different minimum target, or with a stop placed differently relative to the sweep, would show how sensitive the result is to those choices. Changing one rule at a time keeps the comparison clean.

You can run the same test yourself on WickCheck, using the exact rule set and market settings described here, and check whether the numbers match on your own parameters.

Takeaway. On this test, the ICT Silver Bullet rules lost money on both NQ and ES after costs and 1% risk per trade. NQ had a profit factor of 0.46 and a return of -11.8%. ES had a profit factor of 0.9 and a return of -2.1%, which is closer to flat but still negative. Both samples are under 30 trades, so neither result is reliable enough to rank the markets. What the test does show is that the strict sequence of sweep, fair value gap and 2R target rarely completes in this hour, and when it does, it has not paid in this sample.

Run this test yourself

Same rules on ES. Change any word, a market or the dates and see what moves.

Open in WickCheck

Terms used here

Fair value gapLiquidityLiquidity sweepSilver BulletProfit factorStrategy library

Questions

Did the ICT Silver Bullet work on NQ in this test?
No. NQ produced 27 trades with a win rate of 18.5%, a profit factor of 0.46, and a net return of -11.8% at 1% risk per trade after costs. A profit factor under 1 means the strategy lost money.
Is ES better than NQ for the Silver Bullet setup?
In this test, ES lost less. It had a profit factor of 0.9 and a return of -2.1%, compared with 0.46 and -11.8% for NQ. Both samples are under 30 trades, so this is not a reliable ranking of the two markets.
How many trades do I need before trusting a backtest like this?
There is no single number that settles it, but a sample under 30 trades is considered too small to rely on. Longer test periods and more trades per market give a more dependable read on whether a setup holds up.

More tests

EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest Shows

We tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.

Previous Day High Low Strategy: A Backtest Across 4 Markets

We backtested a previous day high low strategy with an FVG entry on ES, XAU/USD, EUR/USD and NQ. Two markets lost money after costs. See the numbers.

Asian Range Strategy: Does the London Sweep Hold Up?

We backtested an Asian range sweep and fair value gap setup on EUR/USD, USD/JPY, GBP/USD and XAU/USD. Results were mixed, with one market profitable.

Follow WickCheck for a new strategy test every day: Instagram · TikTok · X

Past results, real or simulated, do not guarantee future results. Not investment advice.

One tested strategy a week

A popular strategy backtested on real data, with the honest numbers. Free, one email a week, unsubscribe any time.