Order Block Strategy on the 1H Chart With a 200 EMA Filter
Order blocks are one of the most common ideas in trading videos. The claim is usually simple: find the last opposing candle before a strong move, wait for price to come back to it, and trade the bounce in the direction of the move. Adding a 200 EMA trend filter is a popular way to keep only the trades that agree with the broader direction. The question here is whether that combination holds up over a long test with costs included.
The headline finding is mixed, and mostly negative. On three of the four markets tested, the strategy lost money after spread, slippage and 1% risk per trade were accounted for. Only NQ finished positive, with a profit factor of 1.09 and a net return of 115.2% at 1% risk. That result is the only one worth a closer look, and it still needs more testing before anyone should lean on it.
The rules we tested
Buy when price returns into a bullish order block and price is above the 200 EMA. Sell when price returns into a bearish order block and price is below the 200 EMA. Stop at 1.5x ATR. Target 2R.
Results
| Market | Trades | Win rate | Profit factor | Net | Max DD | Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EUR/USD 1h | 1800 | 32.1% | 0.88 | -80.7% | -82.8% | 10y |
| GBP/USD 1h | 1786 | 32.1% | 0.88 | -81.6% | -86.0% | 10y |
| XAU/USD 1h | 1677 | 33.5% | 0.92 | -68.3% | -81.2% | 10y |
| NQ 1h | 1646 | 35.9% | 1.09 | +115.2% | -40.3% | 10y |
1% risk per trade, spread and slippage included, entries at the next candle open, stop checked before target. Periods: EUR/USD 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13 · GBP/USD 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13 · XAU/USD 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13 · NQ 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13.
Equity (% at 1% risk per trade) on NQ 1h, 1646 trades.
What was tested and why
The test looked at bullish and bearish order blocks on the 1 hour chart. A long was taken when price returned into a bullish order block and the close was above the 200 EMA. A short was taken when price returned into a bearish order block and the close was below the 200 EMA. The engine read the rules exactly as follows: Long Bullish order block, retest; Long Close above EMA(200); Short Bearish order block, retest; Short Close below EMA(200).
Stops were set at 1.5 times ATR(14), and targets at 2R. Entries were at the next candle open. If the stop and target were both hit in the same candle, the stop counted first. Costs and 1% risk per trade were included in every figure below.
The period ran from 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13 on EUR/USD, GBP/USD, XAU/USD and NQ. Each market produced between roughly 1,600 and 1,800 trades, so the sample size is not the issue here.
Results by market
EUR/USD produced 1,800 trades with a win rate of 32.1% and a profit factor of 0.88. The average result per trade was -0.08R, and the net return at 1% risk was -80.7%, with a maximum drawdown of 82.8%. A profit factor below 1 means the strategy lost money after costs, and this was the case here.
GBP/USD was almost identical. It produced 1,786 trades, a 32.1% win rate, a profit factor of 0.88 and an average of -0.08R per trade. The net return at 1% risk was -81.6%, with a maximum drawdown of 86%.
XAU/USD lost money as well, though by less. It produced 1,677 trades with a 33.5% win rate, a profit factor of 0.92 and an average of -0.06R per trade. The net return at 1% risk was -68.3%, and the maximum drawdown was 81.2%.
NQ was the only market with a positive result. It produced 1,646 trades, a 35.9% win rate, a profit factor of 1.09 and an average of 0.06R per trade. The net return at 1% risk was 115.2%, with a maximum drawdown of 40.3%. Longs made up 1,057 of those trades and shorts 589.
What stands out: years and long versus short
The yearly figures show how uneven the results were, even in the markets that finished negative overall. On EUR/USD, 2018 was the worst year at -40.8R, and 2023 was the only year with a clearly positive total at 16.9R. On GBP/USD, most years were negative, with 2019 and 2020 contributing the largest losses.
XAU/USD had two strong years in 2025 at 34.5R and 2017 at 8.5R, but also large losing years in 2018 and 2019. A few good years did not offset the rest. NQ was positive in most years through 2024, with 2021 and 2023 standing out, but it turned negative in 2025 at -18.4R and 2026 at -3.3R. The edge in NQ was not steady across the whole period.
On the direction split, NQ took far more longs than shorts, 1,057 against 589. That is worth noting. The test does not show whether the long side carried the result, and it would need a separate breakdown to say so. The EUR/USD and GBP/USD tests were close to evenly split between longs and shorts, and both still lost.
Why it might behave this way
One possible reason is that order blocks are drawn by the reader after the move has happened. Whichever candle a trader marks as the block is often the last opposing candle before a push, and that label is easier to see in hindsight. The rules the engine applied are mechanical, but the underlying idea depends on a visual judgment that is hard to reproduce exactly.
A 2R target with a 1.5 ATR stop needs a win rate above about 33% just to break even before costs. The win rates here were 32.1% on EUR/USD and GBP/USD, which is close to that line, and costs pushed the results below it. A small change in win rate or in average trade size would move these results a lot.
The 200 EMA filter is slow on a 1 hour chart. It may keep the trades on the right side of a broad trend, but it does not say anything about whether the retest will hold. The test does not show how much the filter helped compared with the same rules without it.
What to try next
The most useful next step is to run the same rules without the 200 EMA filter, so the effect of the trend condition can be seen directly. A second test could look at whether the NQ result holds when longs and shorts are reported separately. Testing a different stop multiple or a different target would also show how sensitive the result is to those settings.
Readers who want to check these numbers or change the rules can run the same test themselves on WickCheck. The most useful checks are the yearly breakdown and the cost assumptions, since those are where a result like this one tends to change.
Takeaway. The order block and 200 EMA setup did not hold up well in this test. EUR/USD, GBP/USD and XAU/USD all lost money after costs, with profit factors below 1. NQ was the only positive market, at a profit factor of 1.09, but its results weakened in 2025 and 2026 and it was skewed toward longs. These are results from one set of rules over one ten-year period, not a reason to trade the setup.
Same rules on NQ. Change any word, a market or the dates and see what moves.
Terms used here
Questions
- Does the order block strategy work on the 1 hour chart?
- In this test it did not hold up on EUR/USD, GBP/USD or XAU/USD. All three had profit factors below 1 after costs and 1% risk per trade. NQ was the only market with a profit factor above 1, at 1.09.
- Did adding the 200 EMA filter make the order block strategy profitable?
- This test did not isolate the filter, so it cannot say how much it helped. The rules were tested only with the 200 EMA condition included, and the results were negative on three of four markets. Testing the same rules without the filter would show its effect.
- Is the NQ result reliable enough to trade?
- NQ had 1,646 trades, so the sample is not small, but the edge was uneven. It was negative in 2025 and 2026, and most trades were longs. This is a result to test further, not a reason to trade it.
More tests
We tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Previous Day High Low Strategy: A Backtest Across 4 MarketsWe backtested a previous day high low strategy with an FVG entry on ES, XAU/USD, EUR/USD and NQ. Two markets lost money after costs. See the numbers.
Asian Range Strategy: Does the London Sweep Hold Up?We backtested an Asian range sweep and fair value gap setup on EUR/USD, USD/JPY, GBP/USD and XAU/USD. Results were mixed, with one market profitable.
Past results, real or simulated, do not guarantee future results. Not investment advice.