Fair Value Gap Take Profit: Does a 3R Target Pay?
A common claim on trading videos is that a fair value gap setup works better with a wide target. The idea is that a 3R take profit lets winners run, so the lower win rate is paid back by the bigger wins. The question is whether that holds up once costs and position sizing are applied.
We tested the model on three markets over ten years of 1h data. None of them made money. Profit factor was 0.91 on GBP/USD, 0.93 on EUR/USD and 0.99 on XAU/USD, so each lost money after costs. The 3R target did not rescue the setup.
The rules we tested
Buy when price returns into a bullish fair value gap and price is above the 50 EMA. Sell when price returns into a bearish fair value gap and price is below the 50 EMA. Stop at 1.5x ATR. Target 3R.
Results
| Market | Trades | Win rate | Profit factor | Net | Max DD | Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GBP/USD 1h | 2259 | 24.5% | 0.91 | -84.4% | -89.3% | 10y |
| EUR/USD 1h | 2240 | 24.8% | 0.93 | -78.1% | -87.0% | 10y |
| XAU/USD 1h | 2140 | 26.2% | 0.99 | -42.9% | -86.5% | 10y |
1% risk per trade, spread and slippage included, entries at the next candle open, stop checked before target. Periods: GBP/USD 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13 · EUR/USD 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13 · XAU/USD 2016-11-13 to 2026-11-13.
Equity (% at 1% risk per trade) on XAU/USD 1h, 2140 trades.
What was tested and why
The model looks for a return into a fair value gap, which is a three-candle imbalance, and only takes the trade in the direction of the 50 EMA. A long needs a bullish gap retest with the close above the 50 EMA. A short needs a bearish gap retest with the close below it. The stop sits at 1.5 times the 14-period ATR. The target is 3R, meaning three times the distance from entry to stop. Entries are at the next candle open. Spread, slippage and 1% risk per trade are already included in the results. The engine read the rules as follows: long on a bullish FVG retest, long only when close is above EMA(50), short on a bearish FVG retest, short only when close is below EMA(50), stop at 1.5 times ATR(14), and target at 3R. Nothing else was added. The wider target is the only change from the usual 2R version of this idea, so the test isolates that choice.
Results by market
GBP/USD produced 2,259 trades over the ten years, with a win rate of 24.5%. Profit factor was 0.91 and average R was -0.07. At 1% risk per trade the net return was -84.4%, with a maximum drawdown of 89.3%.
EUR/USD produced 2,240 trades with a win rate of 24.8%. Profit factor was 0.93 and average R was -0.05. Net return at 1% risk was -78.1%, and maximum drawdown was 87%.
XAU/USD produced 2,140 trades with a win rate of 26.2%. Profit factor was 0.99 and average R was -0.01. Net return at 1% risk was -42.9%, and maximum drawdown was 86.5%. This is the closest result to break-even, but it is still a loss after costs. The sample is large in all three markets, with more than 2,000 trades each, so the sizes are not the concern here. The concern is that all three profit factors sit below 1. A profit factor under 1 means the strategy lost money after costs, and that is the case in each row.
What stands out: years and long versus short
The yearly totals are uneven. On GBP/USD, 2021 lost 66.9R and 2023 lost 39.5R, while 2018 and 2025 were positive at 14.1R and 16.7R. EUR/USD had its worst stretch in 2021 and 2022, losing 45.4R and 35.6R, and it made money in 2018 with 24.6R. XAU/USD was the most mixed. It lost 75.2R in 2018 but made 59.4R in 2025 and 33R in 2024. A few strong years do not offset the losing ones, and the net result across the period is still negative in all three markets. Longs and shorts were close in number on each market. GBP/USD had 1,134 longs and 1,125 shorts. EUR/USD had 1,137 longs and 1,103 shorts. XAU/USD had 1,171 longs and 969 shorts. The results here do not break down profit by side, so this report does not say whether one direction carried the losses.
Why it might behave this way
A 3R target needs price to travel three times the stop distance before the trade closes. Over this sample that was reached in about a quarter of trades, with win rates of 24.5% to 26.2%. The wins were larger, but not enough larger to cover the losses at that frequency. Average R close to zero shows the trade-off roughly balanced out, and costs tipped it negative. The 50 EMA filter is a trend condition. In choppy periods, price crosses the average often, and a gap retest may fire on both sides of a range. The yearly swings suggest the model works in some regimes and not others, though this test does not measure regimes directly. The stop rule also matters. Because the stop sits at 1.5 times ATR, a trade can be stopped out on normal noise before the target is reached. When a stop and target are hit in the same candle, the stop counts first, which can cut results further in volatile bars.
What to try next
The most useful next step is to test the 2R version of the same rules on the same data. That shows directly whether the 3R target is what hurts, or whether the entry itself has no edge. Comparing the two on identical markets and periods makes the difference clear. Another test is to remove the 50 EMA filter and see whether the gap retest alone performs differently. A third option is to break results down by session or by year to see whether the losses cluster in certain conditions. Each change should be tested on its own so the cause of any difference is visible. You can run the same test yourself on WickCheck, including changing the target, stop or filter, and comparing the output side by side.
Takeaway. A 3R target did not turn this fair value gap model into a profitable one. On GBP/USD, EUR/USD and XAU/USD over ten years of 1h data, profit factor stayed below 1 and average R was slightly negative. Winners were bigger at 3R, but they were too rare to make up for the losses. Any test that tries to fix this should change one rule at a time and be judged on costs, drawdown and year-by-year results, not on a single headline win rate.
Same rules on XAU/USD. Change any word, a market or the dates and see what moves.
Terms used here
Questions
- Is a 3R target better than 2R for fair value gap trades?
- This test does not answer that directly, because it only ran the 3R version. On these three markets the 3R model had profit factors of 0.91 to 0.99, which means it lost money after costs. Testing the 2R version on the same data is the clean way to compare them.
- Did the fair value gap model make money on gold?
- XAU/USD came closest to break-even, with a profit factor of 0.99 and average R of -0.01 over 2,140 trades. It still lost money after costs, with a net return of -42.9% at 1% risk per trade and a maximum drawdown of 86.5%.
- Can I run this test myself?
- Yes. You can run the same rules on WickCheck, change the target, stop or filter, and compare the results. Check the trade count and profit factor before drawing any conclusions.
More tests
We tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Previous Day High Low Strategy: A Backtest Across 4 MarketsWe backtested a previous day high low strategy with an FVG entry on ES, XAU/USD, EUR/USD and NQ. Two markets lost money after costs. See the numbers.
Asian Range Strategy: Does the London Sweep Hold Up?We backtested an Asian range sweep and fair value gap setup on EUR/USD, USD/JPY, GBP/USD and XAU/USD. Results were mixed, with one market profitable.
Past results, real or simulated, do not guarantee future results. Not investment advice.