Break of Structure Strategy: 2,003 Trades Tested
A break of structure (BOS) is how smart money traders confirm a trend: price closes beyond the last swing high in an uptrend, or the last swing low in a downtrend.
We traded every BOS in the direction of the 200 EMA for 10 years on five markets. It was close to break-even everywhere, and the costs tipped most of it into a loss.
- EUR/USD 1-hour, 10 years: 2,003 trades, 33% winners, profit factor 0.95, −58.0% at 1% risk.
- Gold (1.03) and Nasdaq futures (1.03) were slightly profitable; GBP/USD lost (0.91); S&P 500 futures broke even (1.00).
- Almost every year on EUR/USD was negative; 2022 alone lost 28.4R.
- A BOS confirms a trend that already happened. On its own it is too common to be an edge.
In this guide: What is a break of structure? · The exact rules · The result on EUR/USD · Same rules on 5 markets · How traders actually use BOS
What is a break of structure?
!img /media/blog/break-of-structure-strategy/h4-bos-diagram.webp | Diagram of a bullish break of structure: a candle closes above the last swing high | Bullish BOS: a close above the last swing high.
In an uptrend, price makes higher highs and higher lows. A bullish break of structure happens when a candle closes above the last swing high, confirming the trend is continuing. A bearish BOS is the mirror image. It's different from a change of character (CHoCH), which is the first break against the trend.
The exact rules
Buy on a bullish break of structure when price is above the 200 EMA. Sell on a bearish break of structure when price is below the 200 EMA. Stop at 2x ATR. Target 2R.
1-hour candles, November 2016 to November 2026, 1% risk per trade, spread and commission included.
The result on EUR/USD
!img /media/blog/break-of-structure-strategy/h-equity.webp | Equity curve of the break of structure strategy on EUR/USD 1-hour over 10 years, down 58% | 2,003 trades on EUR/USD: a slow, steady decline.
2,003 trades, 33% winners, a profit factor of 0.95, an average of −0.03R per trade and −58.0% at 1% risk, with a maximum drawdown of −63.6%. Numbers are from the WickCheck strategy library as of 19 November 2026. The library re-runs every test as new candles arrive, so the live pages can differ slightly.
!img /media/blog/break-of-structure-strategy/h-years.webp | Year-by-year results of the break of structure strategy on EUR/USD in R | Only three positive years out of ten on EUR/USD.
Only 2018 (+0.6R), 2020 (+3.5R) and 2025 (+7.4R) were positive. 2022 was the worst at −28.4R.
Same rules on 5 markets
!img /media/blog/break-of-structure-strategy/h-markets.webp | Profit factor of the break of structure strategy on EUR/USD, GBP/USD, gold, Nasdaq futures and S&P 500 futures | Everything sits close to 1.00: no real edge on any market.
- Gold: 1.03, +14.6%.
- Nasdaq 100 futures: 1.03, +22.5%.
- S&P 500 futures: 1.00, −15.4%.
- EUR/USD: 0.95, −58.0%.
- GBP/USD: 0.91, −75.7%.
When every market sits between 0.91 and 1.03, the honest reading is that the rule on its own has no edge, and costs decide the sign. The two slight positives came with drawdowns of 35–50%.
How traders actually use BOS
Most smart money traders don't trade every BOS. They use it as confirmation inside a bigger setup: a higher-timeframe bias, a sweep of liquidity, then a BOS on a lower timeframe, then an entry in a fair value gap or an order block. Each extra condition cuts the number of trades. Whether it adds an edge is something only a test can tell you.
Bottom line. Trading every break of structure with a 200 EMA filter was close to break-even on all five markets over 10 years, and lost after costs on most. Use BOS as confirmation inside a tested setup, not as the setup.
Combine BOS with a sweep, a session or a higher-timeframe bias in plain English.
Questions
- What is a break of structure in trading?
- A candle closing beyond the last swing high (bullish BOS) or swing low (bearish BOS), confirming the trend is continuing.
- Does trading break of structure work?
- Trading every BOS with a 200 EMA filter was close to break-even in WickCheck's 10-year 1-hour test: profit factor 0.95 on EUR/USD over 2,003 trades, 1.03 on gold and Nasdaq futures, 0.91 on GBP/USD.
- What is the difference between BOS and CHoCH?
- A BOS breaks structure in the direction of the trend. A change of character (CHoCH) is the first break against the trend, an early sign it may be reversing.
Keep reading
We tested the ICT order block strategy on every signal for 3 years on EUR/USD, GBP/USD, gold, Nasdaq and S&P 500 futures. Here is what happened.
Fair Value Gaps Explained With Real Charts (and Whether They Work)What a fair value gap is, how to spot bullish and bearish FVGs, a real gold example, and what trading every FVG for 10 years did on 5 markets.
Which Trading Strategies Actually Work? 15 Backtested on Real DataWe backtested 15 popular trading strategies, from ICT setups to RSI and moving averages, on years of real data with costs. Here is what held up.
EMA Crossover Strategy on Gold: What the Backtest ShowsWe tested the 9/21 EMA crossover with a 200 EMA filter on gold, EUR/USD and the Nasdaq, with costs included. Gold lost money after costs over 10 years.
Educational content, not investment advice. Trading involves risk of loss.